The Rings

So I've been pining over the famous Elizabeth & James knuckle ring for soo long now, and hoping I will magically spot it somewhere or something similar, and I've had absolutely no luck... Until a couple of days ago. They aren't exactly like it, but they are quite a thrilling substitute. I bought both because I wasn't sure which I liked more, so I might still return one. Only problem is the sizes arent quite right, anyways tell me what you think, keep both, or one.. which one!?